Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

'Agnostic' - Do We Even Care?

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

'Agnostic' - Do We Even Care?

Article excerpt

"What's with agnostic?" a reader writes. "Could you illuminate this subject (if not eradicate it, before it takes over like a fungus)?"

I'm happy to. Who wants to be taken over by a fungus?

Agnostic was coined by T.H. Huxley in 1870 to describe "one who professes that the existence of a First Cause and the essential nature of things are not and cannot be known." For his neologism he drew on a Greek word meaning "unknown." So agnostic has been traditionally used to refer to the knowledge - or not - of God.

Now it's being applied to those who don't know, and hence don't have an opinion on, other things. It's a highbrow way of saying, "I don't have a dog in that fight."

Does this new meaning serve a need - or will it ruin the word for its original purpose?

Dealing with a word in transition is like being on one of those "articulated" subway cars, the ones with a joint in the middle, on the MBTA system here in Boston. Your footing may be a little unsteady until the car has turned the corner.

The new "agnostic" may be most useful in situations such as this: "I don't know, and I don't need to know, what goes on with X before I see it. But here's what I need X to do or be when I do see it."

Thus, on a Friday afternoon, a boss may say frankly to a troublesome employee: "You've been giving off such bad vibes around here that the geraniums in the break room are dying. You really need to get yourself straightened out over the weekend. I'm agnostic on how you do it, but you've got to have a better attitude when you come in Monday morning."

The Greek derivation may give "agnostic" a certain dignity and may signal a willingness to suspend judgment. But unless the "don't know" clearly has "don't need to know and maybe can't know" folded into it, it's hard to make the case for this use of "agnostic." (Of course, if someone really just doesn't know, there's the Latin- derived adjective "ignorant. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.