Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Letters to the Editor

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Letters to the Editor

Article excerpt

Did the Jena 6 nooses constitute a hate crime?

The Oct. 24 Opinion piece by Craig Franklin, "Media myths about the Jena 6," stated that no hate crime could be prosecuted at Jena and that the nooses were not aimed at black students but instead at white rodeo-team members.

Then a Nov. 30 Opinion piece by Sen. Edward Kennedy and Rep. John Lewis states, "We must not tolerate hate crimes," implying once again that these events at Jena were racerelated.

This difference of opinion points up a difficult decision that prosecutors and investigators must face with hate-crime legislation.

Can any of the authors prove that the motivation was hate, specifically related to one of the selected criteria?

Further, Mr. Franklin states, "It remains unclear why Mr. [Justin] Barker was specifically targeted" but that "police speculate that the motivation of the attack was related to racially charged fights."

Is it not possible to conceive that racially motivated hate might have played some part in the attack on him?

Would this then become a hate crime to be equally targeted and prosecuted under the Kennedy-Lewis legislation?

Would the intervention of federal authority somehow assure fair prosecution where the state or local officials have been unfair? Or is this a knee-jerk reaction that will only create more paperwork, longer sentences, and less real progress in learning to live in peace with one another?

Roger Lachele Dallas

US naive in negotiations with Iran

In response to the Nov. 30 article, "Iran reformers: Let's talk": Unfortunately for any proposed talks between the US and Iran to succeed, there must be a resolution of the problem that exists, namely the ability of the supreme Iranian ruler Ayatollah Khamenei to veto any agreement that does not encompass the aim of destroying Israel and obtaining hegemony over the Middle East.

If we are naive enough to be drawn into negotiations with the current rulers of Iran, we can only expect that they will receive one-sided concessions from us. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.