Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Rebuilding the Indian Nations by Enforcing Old Treaties and Laws, John Echohawk and NARF Restore Tribal Sovereignty. INTERVIEW

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Rebuilding the Indian Nations by Enforcing Old Treaties and Laws, John Echohawk and NARF Restore Tribal Sovereignty. INTERVIEW

Article excerpt

LAW school was a revelation to John E. Echohawk, a Pawnee. As a student at the University of New Mexico in the mid-1960s he discovered a body of laws governing Indian affairs that he had never heard about.

"Our tribal leaders knew nothing about the laws that already existed," recounts Mr. Echohawk, relaxing in the lawbook-lined conference room of the Native American Rights Fund (NARF) offices here. "None of us knew. We were not informed about them in school. A law doesn't do any good until it is enforced. So we had to learn the legal process."

There were but 20 American Indian lawyers in the practice at the time. The only Indian law casebook was a loose-leaf collection of federal statutes and Indian treaties assembled by a law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles.

Today, there are perhaps 700 American Indian lawyers practicing. And the nonprofit organization Mr. Echohawk helped found 20 years ago has worked to enforce the existing laws on behalf of more than 75 tribes and Eskimo communities, NARF clients.

Perhaps the primary achievement of the organization has been to restore the sovereignty of American Indian nations.

"There has been more litigation in the last 20 years than in the previous 200 on behalf of the Indians," says Echohawk, who has been director of NARF for the past 15 years. "Federal policy now recognizes the right of Indian people to self-determination - the right to control our own affairs."

It hasn't been easy. NARF's all-Indian board of directors decides which cases the 18-lawyer organization will take up - cases that often drag on for years and absorb lots of cash. Fees make up only about 5 percent of the operating costs for the nonprofit group. The rest comes from government grants, individual contributions, and corporate funding.

"There are few lawyers and very little money," says Echohawk. "So those priorities involve those issues most important to Indian country." (Echohawk would not comment on the ongoing Mohawk Indian dispute in Canada, saying NARF deals only with United States Indian affairs.)

Sovereignty issues include tribal status, natural resources jurisdiction, education, and the "right of Indian people to live as Indians," says Ecohawk.

NARF has represented various tribes wishing to regain their status as tribes. One precedent-setting case involved the Menominee tribe of Wisconsin. Congress had terminated the Menominees' status as a tribal government in the 1950s as part of a policy aimed at cultural assimilation and dismantling the Bureau of Indian Affairs. Without federal protection, the tribe was subject only to state laws, including taxation. Tribal members were forced to sell off land to pay taxes.

"We made the case to Congress that the termination decision had been disastrous to the people who had lost much of their land," Echohawk says. "In 1973 there was a dramatic reversal and the tribe's status was restored to them. Since then, a dozen or so other tribes have had their status restored. We've handled two or three ourselves."

Most of these cases have involved battles of jurisdiction between the states and the federal government to regulate activities on the reservations. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.