Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Staten Island Votes Whether to Study Possible Secession

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Staten Island Votes Whether to Study Possible Secession

Article excerpt

STOP the city. Staten Island wants to get off.

Informal polls suggest that a majority of voters here will say "yes" today to the first, most basic step in seceding from New York City. If the referendum is approved, a commission will be created to draft a charter for a new City of Staten Island.

Legally and economically, the question of whether this relatively affluent, suburban, and isolated borough could ever really strike off on its own is still a long way from resolution. The state Legislature, which last year approved a bill allowing today's vote, would have to give the final approval.

Supporters portray today's vote as essentially a study move rather than a firm commitment. "It's a vote to look at the process and decide down the road," says Gary Johnson, a Staten Island lawyer who heads a nonprofit group called Staten Island-Vote Yes Inc. Under the current plan, Staten Island voters would return to the polls in 1993 to accept, reject, or urge revision of the drafted charter.

A straw poll published Oct. 28 by the Staten Island Advance, the island's main newspaper showed two-thirds favor the first step. This paper's editorials support the charter commission.

Even Staten Island borough president Guy Molinari, a former US congressman who has voiced considerable skepticism about whether the secession effort can and should succeed, says he will probably vote yes. He will ask the state for financial help to conduct a top professional study on the issue. The three studies done so far have not been satisfactory, he says.

The emotional appeal of secession has deep roots among "islanders." They complain of unfair city treatment in everything from garbage to transport services. Most irritating to many islanders is the Fresh Kills landfill, the recipient of most New York City garbage.

Just recently city sanitation officials requested a permit to dump even more there - some 1,800 tons of incinerator ash every day. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.