Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Shared Control Tests Christian Churches' Mettle CHURCH OF THE NATIVITY

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Shared Control Tests Christian Churches' Mettle CHURCH OF THE NATIVITY

Article excerpt

ALL across the Holy Land, the rain that fell last Friday to end a protracted drought was welcomed as a blessing.

Except, that is, at the Church of the Nativity, built over the manger where Jesus is said to have been born. Here monks readied basins and buckets to catch water leaking through the roof that they cannot agree to mend.

For this Christmas finds the three Christian communities that share the church locked in another round of their centuries-old dispute over who has the right to do what with their particular corner.

The Basilica of the Nativity, one of the earliest churches and holiest sites in Christendom, was built by the Greek Orthodox in the fourth century and subsequently also used by the Armenian Church and the Roman Catholic crusaders. The current dispute over who should mend the roof is another in a long line of arguments that has arisen among the Greeks, Armenians, and Latins, as the Catholics are known, who maintain competing claims to different parts of the church with an intensity that bewilders outsiders.

The Rev. Jerry Murphy O'Connor, a Catholic archaeologist who has lived in Jerusalem for nearly 30 years, ascribes the passion to "the whole ethos of this area - the tradition that you're only really secure if you're in total control."

In an effort to avoid earlier disputes over ownership, the Ottoman Empire, which controlled the Holy Land for centuries, issued edicts in the middle of the 19th century known as the "status quo," freezing all attempts to modify the churches' traditional rights. Codified under the British Mandate in Palestine earlier this century, the "status quo" goes into extraordinary detail.

"The Latins have the right of passage to their Church and Convent" adjacent to the Basilica "through the Basilica, in between the first and second pillars of the Northern rows," the document reads. It warns, though, that "attempts on various occasions have been made by the Latins to pass between the second and third pillars."

The dispute over who should mend the leaking roof has arisen, like other similar arguments in the past, because "doing repairs is a way of showing your rights" to ownership, explains Shmuel Hamburger, the man in charge of religious affairs for the Israeli occupation authorities in the West Bank. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.