Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

In Many Places, the West and Islam Aren't in Conflict

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

In Many Places, the West and Islam Aren't in Conflict

Article excerpt

ONE of the ironies of the current world scene is that the Christian West, including the United States, despite fears expressed over the spread of Islam, is exerting major efforts to protect Muslim populations. In some cases the actions are against nominally Christian governments.

The bulk of the people of Bosnia to whom relief supplies are being flown are Muslim, under heavy attack by forces who claim allegiance to the Serbian Orthodox Church. The Somalis, also being aided by a largely Western relief effort, are Muslim. The action to establish a "no fly" zone over southern Iraq is intended to protect people adhering to one branch of Islam, Shia, from the Sunni government in Baghdad. But the Kurds in the North, also being protected against Baghdad, are Sunni Muslims.

The current situation suggests that religious categories do not accurately reflect the nature of a regime nor the degree to which that regime's policies are friendly or unfriendly to other countries.

The "ethnic cleansing" of Greater Serbia is plainly identified with the Serbian Orthodox Church, but the true motivation is the effort to maintain a former communist leadership structure in place.

In southern Iraq, the Shia revolt arises from opposition to a repressive government in Baghdad inattentive to the needs and interests of the peoples of the south. These Shia do not seek to join their fellow religionists in Iran. They did not rise to support Tehran when the Iraq-Iran war broke out in 1980. They are Arabs, by tradition, ethnic origin, and language. It is that orientation - not their religious faith - that has determined their politics.

In recent years, concerns in the US over developments in the Middle East have been expressed in terms of a fear of "Islamic fundamentalism," related to America's experience with the revolution in Iran. The angry anti-American and anti-Western tones of that Shia-led movement, however, had as much to do with Western governments' identity with the deposed shah as they did with religion.

The directions of countries that are often seen as "fundamentalist," including Iran, grow out of secular circumstances: mass unemployment, the disorientation of a young population, anger at corruption, or fear of outside influences on the social structure. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.