Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Israelis Are Split on US Election Level of Foreign Policy Activism Frames the Debate in Israel over Presidential Campaign

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Israelis Are Split on US Election Level of Foreign Policy Activism Frames the Debate in Israel over Presidential Campaign

Article excerpt

AS Israelis watch the United States presidential campaign unfold, their feelings about the outcome offer yet another illustration of how the particularities of Middle East politics can transcend normal logic.

Members of the right-wing opposition Likud Party are, in general, backing not the conservative Republican candidacy of President Bush, as one might expect, but his Democratic rival, Gov. Bill Clinton. And the left-leaning Laborites in government are quietly hoping that Mr. Bush will manage to win reelection.

Though government officials, wary of the outcome of the Nov. 3 vote, will not comment publicly on the US presidential race, Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin "is betting on Bush, no doubt about it," says Gabi Sheffer, an expert on US-Israeli relations at Hebrew University.

To some extent, that preference derives from Mr. Rabin's familiarity with Bush and his former secretary of state, James Baker III, who engineered the current Middle East peace process, while the Arkansas governor is an unknown quantity. `Smooth sailing'

Though Mr. Clinton has gone out of his way to make statements sympathetic to Israel, "they are still only statements," says Susan Hattis Rolef, editor of the Labor Party magazine Spectrum.

"From Bush, this government has got the loan guarantees," she adds, "and it is smooth sailing."

At the same time, there is a widespread feeling among Israeli politicians and analysts across the political spectrum that by denying $10 billion in loan guarantees for immigrant absorption to former Premier Yitzhak Shamir, and cooling US-Israeli relations, the Bush administration deliberately contributed to the Likud's defeat in elections last June.

"The Americans did not hide that they wanted Rabin elected, and they did their utmost to help him," Dr. Sheffer says. Rabin's reciprocal support for Bush, he suggests - evidenced in part by Israel's low-key protests about the planned US sale of F-15 fighter planes to Saudi Arabia - "is part of the implicit deal. There is a personal, political commitment."

The perception that Bush helped Rabin defeat Mr. Shamir also explains the deep resentment that many Likud politicians hold against the US president.

"He was involved up to his neck in Israeli politics to pull down Shamir," complains Likud parliament member Ron Nahman, and as he crafted the current peace process, "Baker used pressure on Israel when he didn't have to. I don't think Clinton and {vice-presidential candidate Sen. Al} Gore would do the same thing.

"I vote for Clinton," says Mr. Nahman, also the mayor of the West Bank settlement of Ariel.

Bush's foreign policy activism and his readiness to put pressure on Israel might prove a problem for the Israeli government in the future. If negotiations with Syria and the Palestinians reached critical and delicate junctures at some stage, Israelis expect that Bush's large investment in Middle East peace would lead him to exert pressure for concessions. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.