Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Michener's Bullfighting Metaphor

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Michener's Bullfighting Metaphor

Article excerpt

JAMES A. MICHENER could have called his book "Mexico" "The Matadors."

The story line is of two bullfighters: a bowlegged, taciturn Mexican Indian and a lean, graceful Spanish torero. The narrator, John Clay, is a 52-year-old American journalist born in Mexico, who returns to cover a showdown between the antagonists.

Thus Michener establishes the means to explore the primary historical and cultural influences - in the scope and detail of Michener classics - that converge to create Mexico today. Although set in 1961, when Michener researched the novel, time has spun no cobwebs on the observations.

Michener acknowledges that most bullfights are disgraceful, cowardly exhibitions that leave the beast looking like a four-legged pincushion. But he also examines cultural biases against bullfighting and explains why aficionados consider it not a sport but a Spanish art form.

At its finest, Michener says, "for twelve minutes out there on the sand you will see something that occurs nowhere else on this earth, the perfect duel between life and death.... You will see men on their toes daintily throwing their lives upon the horns, and at the end you will watch a man with a frail piece of cloth play a bull to death. People will scream with insanity from the tension. Horses far from the scene will neigh, and when it is all over you will sit limp as death yourself."

To understand the Mexican psyche and bullfighting, says a Mexican bullfight critic in the novel, one must understand the Spanish fascination with death. While English literature often explores immortality, he notes, in Spanish literature life is a preparation for death.

"If Spaniards are preoccupied with death, it is because our greatest men have taught us to be so," the critic says. "If we love bullfights it is because we subconsciously know that this is the world's only art form that depicts our preoccupation. …

Author Advanced search


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.