Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Human Rights in S. Asia Should Concern US

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Human Rights in S. Asia Should Concern US

Article excerpt

In response to the editorial "Talbott Passage to India," April 7, I take exception to the assessment that the Clinton administration blundered in developing relations with India.

The editorial equates Assistant Secretary of State Robin Raphael's statements of United States policy on Kashmir with questioning India's sovereignty. Her statements do no such thing. Ms. Raphael's statements have only been a reiteration of long-standing US policy toward Kashmir, based on the United Nations Security Council resolutions of 1948 and 1949 that call for a plebiscite in Kashmir to allow its citizens to determine their own political future.

As the editorial points out, this dispute has resulted in massive human rights abuses in Kashmir. More than 25,000 people have been killed in the valley since 1990, and an average of 15 people a day continue to die because of the dispute. India's 500,000 security forces in Kashmir are also responsible for what the US State Department and human rights groups have called "significant" human rights abuses against Kashmiri people.

Your solution to the dispute and the US-India diplomatic row is putting "pressure on India, not questioning borders." This solution might be possible had Kashmir been part of India. But as the UN resolutions - reiterated by US policy - declare, this is not the case. Kashmir is a disputed territory.

The answer lies in two parts: Confidence building and political dialogue.

A process of confidence-building measures should first include a reduction of India's military presence in Kashmir and an immediate end to the human rights abuses. Corresponding to this would be a reduction of militant activity in the valley.

Once confidence has been established, India, Pakistan, and the people of Kashmir will be able to engage in a peaceful dialogue.

In order to effectively participate in such a dialogue, the Kashmiri people have organized the All Parties Freedom (Hurriyat) Conference. The Hurriyat is comprised of 34 Kashmiri parties spanning the political spectrum. The Hurriyat's mandate is to achieve a peaceful solution. The government of India has beaten and imprisoned much of the organization's leadership. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.