Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

France's Costly Antiterror War

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

France's Costly Antiterror War

Article excerpt

THE gun battle was unequal: a squadron of eight paratroopers and two gendarmes against a young man at a lonely bus stop in central France last Friday evening. When it was over, Khaled Kelkal lay dead.

Kelkal had become France's Public Enemy No. 1. His fingerprints were identified on the tape attaching the detonator to one of the bombs in this summer's harrowing series: 55 pounds of explosive powder, nails, and bolts packed inside a butane gas canister, on the Paris-to-Lyon high-speed rail line. For three days preceding his death, he was the target of a full-blown manhunt. Eight hundred civilian and military police officers, equipped with dogs, infrared binoculars, and three helicopters, combed a patch of woods where his trail had been lost after a shootout.

In contrast to certain American examples of police use of force - in Waco, Texas, for instance - the gendarmes were doubtless within the law in killing Kelkal. Not only was he implicated in at least two of the terrorist attacks that have traumatized the country since July, he was also shooting at the police.

Still, that may not be enough to forestall the damage that inevitably results from incidents like this in which a war logic prevails.

The problem is that Kelkal, terrorists' apprentice though he may have been, was no enemy from without. Growing up in a typical lower-class immigrant neighborhood, he was a good student at a reputable high school before he fell in with a band of petty criminals and served time in jail. Kelkal and his kind are an integral part of French society.

While some housing-project kids were, in their words, "ashamed of Khaled because he confused Islam and violence," many others - who disapprove of his aims and methods - couldn't help rooting for him as he eluded the spectacular deployment of men in uniform.

By early September, the maximum-security plan named "Vigipirate," with its 2,300 soldiers and 90,000 military police officers, had changed the face of French towns. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.