Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

What's Behind Latest White House Scandal? FBI FILEGATE

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

What's Behind Latest White House Scandal? FBI FILEGATE

Article excerpt

With nary a moment to catch our breath from the Senate's concluded Whitewater investigation, Congress has plunged right into the next Clinton administration intrigue: the case of the wayward FBI files.

Already the flap has attained the aura of scandal, the requisite "gate" suffix incorporated into its moniker, "Filegate." Indeed, Republicans hint that the case - in which a White House office improperly requested from the FBI 481 background files, mainly of departed officials from Republican administrations - involves Watergate-esque abuses of executive power.

Others hark back to the era of longtime FBI director J. Edgar Hoover, who routinely used his agency to invade citizens' privacy at the White House's request. Democrats agree that the acquisition of the files was a gross violation of privacy, but they are so far giving the Clinton administration the benefit of the doubt. The White House claims incompetence, not malice.

A congressional committee began hearings on the matter this week. Following are some questions pertinent to the case:

*So far, what is reported to have happened?

In 1993, Craig Livingstone, a political appointee who directed the White House's office of personnel security, was asked to create current security files on employees from previous administrations who still needed White House access. So he got a friend, a civilian Army investigator named Anthony Marceca, detailed to the White House to help with the project.

Mr. Marceca got what turned out to be an outdated list of White House passholders - a list of more than 400 names that included former Secretary of State James Baker III and White House spokesman Marlin Fitzwater. Marceca says he got the list from a retiring employee, and that he was unaware the list was out of date. That employee, Nancy Gemmell, told Congress Wednesday that she did not hand Marceca a list, and that the only list she knew of was one from the Secret Service that she had "left behind at the time of my departure."

Marceca, who has not testified yet to Congress, says he gave the list he had - its origin still unclear - to the FBI, which responded routinely. Files were handed over between December 1993 and February 1994, at which point Marceca left the White House and a replacement aide came in. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.