Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Rumors of German-Israeli Nuclear Missile Deal Pique Debate on 'Special Relationship'

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Rumors of German-Israeli Nuclear Missile Deal Pique Debate on 'Special Relationship'

Article excerpt

German leaders have always made support for Israel's security a part of their foreign policy, but as the Holocaust recedes into the past, fewer Germans agree.

"Special Relationship" is a term used to describe the relations between Great Britain and the US, but if ever there were two countries linked by historical events of unparalleled magnitude, it is Germany and Israel. The Holocaust has defined the relationship between the country of the perpetrators and the country of the victims, so much so that German Chancellor Angela Merkel frequently calls the security of the Jewish state Germany's responsibility, its "raison d'etre" even.

But not all Germans agree, and the decisions Mrs. Merkel makes based on that "special relationship" stir growing unease among many Germans.

This week Der Spiegel magazine ran a cover story about German submarines being sold to Israel. The article quotes several former members of the German defense ministry alleging that Israel is arming these submarines, delivered at very generous terms, with nuclear cruise missiles and that the German government has been aware of this modification for quite some time.

Neither German nor Israeli officials have commented on the story, but experts see it as an open secret. The fact that Berlin is not even denying it has led the political opposition and commentators to re-open the debate on the character of German-Israeli relations.

"The submarines are a vital addition to our national security," Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told German tabloid Bild in an interview on June 5. "They are an affirmation of Germany's commitment to Israel's security."

"Of course the German government never asked what would happen to these subs," says Karsten Voigt, a former Social Democrat member of parliament and government coordinator for US-German relations. "The worst thing would have been if the Israelis had said the truth - any German government would have had a hard time defending itself."

There is no lack of critics. Gunter Grass, a Nobel-Prize-winning German author, found himself at the center of an international scandal when he published a poem a few weeks ago in which he defended Iran against the threat of a military strike by Israel and asked the - rhetorical - question of whether Germany should be part of a nuclear arms race in the Middle East.

"I'm speaking out," Mr. Grass said in his poem, "because my country, scene of crimes beyond comparison, under the pretext of penitence is sending Israel another submarine, which can direct all- destructive warheads toward an area in which not a single nuclear bomb as been proven to exist."

The poem drew condemnation around the globe, notably in Israel, where Grass was declared persona non-grata. In Germany it rekindled the debate on whether criticism of Israel was equivalent to anti- Semitism or a liberation from the decades of guilt. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.