In Looming Federalism Fight, Three States Say Feds Can't 'Unmarry' Gay Couples

Article excerpt

Three states where members of the clergy and justices of the peace today marry gay couples argued on Friday that its a violation of states rights for the federal government to then unmarry those people under the 1996 Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA).

In an amicus brief to a New York case involving a lesbian widow, Vermont, Connecticut, and New York argue that the federal government had no right, despite the federal designation of marriage as being between a man and a woman, to demand $350,000 in estate taxes when Edie Windsors partner died. That would not have happened under a marital tax deduction that lets other married couples pass their assets to their spouse without penalty.

The three states who filed amicus briefs argue that states regulate marriage and family relationships and that Congress doesnt have constitutional authority to interfere with that license at any level.

Obama vs. Romney 101: 4 ways they differ on gay issues

Several federal and state judges have struck down parts of DOMA, but it was only earlier this year that a federal appeals court in Boston, called it discriminatory regarding partner benefits, saying the law fails the test when looking at its disparate impact on minority interests and federalism concerns.

The First Circuit panel, however, did not rule on the most controversial aspect of the law, and perhaps its ultimate federalist test: Whether gay marriages are legal, or reciprocal, in states that have laws against the practice.

Meanwhile, the fight between Congress and the Obama administration over how to defend DOMA has added more questions about how far Congress is willing to go to exert its will on the states.

The House Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group (BLAG), led by Speaker John Boehner (R), has taken over defending the law after President Obama said his administration would not a refusal that DOMA defenders have written is an unprecedented deviation from the historical norm. …


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.