Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

What History Should Record of the Boston Bombings

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

What History Should Record of the Boston Bombings

Article excerpt

Perhaps more than recent mass killings in America, the Boston Marathon bombings caused quite a common and massive response - of togetherness.

In the days after the bombings, federal, state, and local police as well as local residents displayed incredible cooperation in the capture of the suspects, Tamerlan and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev. Thousands of videos, tweets, and other bits of information from citizens came together in a wealth of evidence and reporting.

Then thousands of people turned out for a healing service held by multiple faiths and attended by three levels of government - the mayor, the Massachusetts governor, and President Obama.

And on the one-week anniversary of the blasts, throngs of Boston- area residents joined in a moment of silence near the bomb site and elsewhere. People are still bonding in a "Boston Strong" campaign, such as soliciting donations for the victims and their families.

These displays of a shared humanity, however, haven't received nearly as much attention as speculation over how the Tsarnaev brothers were so very different from the people they attacked. The two have became categorized, either as disgruntled immigrants, jihadists, loners, or assorted other psychological "types." For journalists and politicians, this "us versus them" divide is an easy sell while the other news - the collective response - is more fleeting and perhaps even boring.

For David Cannadine, a Princeton University historian and the author of 14 books, this sort of fixation on divisions is a big problem. In his latest book, "The Undivided Past," the professor takes to task a tendency among scholars and others (not least the media) to focus on the "allegedly impermeable divides" between people. He pleads that we focus more on the sweep of history that shows just how united we all are.

His main point lies in the subtitle - "humanity beyond our differences" - as well as in his summation: "humanity is still here."

Historians, journalists, and political leaders often ignore the fact that most people do not live out their lives in a clash of identities, he says. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.