Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

After Military Ouster of Egypt's Morsi, a Chance to Get It Right

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

After Military Ouster of Egypt's Morsi, a Chance to Get It Right

Article excerpt

Any democracy should help define a people's identity as well as reconcile their differences. Even established ones have difficulty with either purpose. For Egypt, its newly minted democracy failed on both. That is what triggered this week's popular uprising that pushed the Army to oust a president, Mohammed Morsi, who was elected only a year ago.

Whether the ouster is called a coup or a protective necessity, either way the events in Cairo on Wednesday serve as a lesson on why many democracies have faltered in recent years. People are less trusting of elected leaders. They hold differing views on religion's role in governance. And they are disillusioned over government's ability to create jobs. And with the Internet, mass movements are better able to challenge leaders.

Egypt's revolution in 2011 as part of the Arab Spring held the promise of creating a democracy based on political trust, religious tolerance, and economic talent. The country had two recent models in nearby Tunisia and Turkey. In both, the military has been kept in the barracks by the ability of civilian groups to trust each other enough to create a consensus over democratic essentials, such as minority rights and a clear separation of powers.

And in each, Islam-based parties have a healthy respect for the secular principles of democracy while government allows free expression of religious views in politics. This is what Columbia University scholar Alfred Stepan calls the "twin tolerations" necessary to reconcile Islam and democracy.

Since 2011, Egyptians failed in developing such mutual trust between differing groups. The youthful pro-democracy activists could not unite in the post-dictator era while the Muslim Brotherhood broke promise after promise to its opponents, using its dominance in rural Egypt to win elections.

Mr. Morsi, once a leader in the group, violated the most basic democratic principles by assuming absolute power over the judiciary. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.