Newspaper article

Efforts to Curb Unnecessary Care Are under Way, but Face Well- Funded Opposition

Newspaper article

Efforts to Curb Unnecessary Care Are under Way, but Face Well- Funded Opposition

Article excerpt

Public efforts to debunk the prevailing "more is better" attitude about medical care tend to elicit scare-mongering charges of rationing. But futile and unnecessary medical care is a major health issue -- one that affects all of us.

Fortunately, some people are trying to do something about it. On Tuesday, the journal BMJ published a news feature on those efforts, led by many prominent doctors in the United States, Canada and Great Britain.

As reporter Jeanne Lenzer points out, overtreatment is both costly and deadly. "Overly aggressive treatment is estimated to cause 30,000 deaths among Medicare recipients alone each year," she writes. "Overall, unnecessary interventions are estimated to account for 10-30% of spending on healthcare in the US." That adds up to $250 billion to $800 billion annually.

In her article, Lenzer summarizes the discussions that occurred at a two-day conference last April in Cambridge, Mass., the first- ever medical meeting in the U.S. to focus exclusively on "avoiding avoidable care":

The group identified multiple reasons that clinicians and hospitals overtreat, including malpractice fears, supply driven demand, knowledge gaps, biased research, profit seeking, patient demand, and financial conflicts of guideline writers. Other commonly cited problems included the rapid uptake of unproved technology and the failure to inform patients fully of the potential harms of elective treatments. ...

Several speakers emphasized the way physicians are paid and trained n the US as central factors. [Dr. Diane Meier, who won a MacArthur "genius grant' in 2008 for her work in palliative care,] told the BMJ, "Medical students are taught to do things, not how to know what not to do. Medicine is a very action based profession, and that's how physicians in the US are paid, perhaps not coincidentally. You don't get paid for telling people that watching and waiting might be best, or that keeping someone comfortable might be better." The result is that overtreatment is woven through American medical culture -- as one participant said, "It's in the air we breathe."

Growing public awareness

The recent global downturn and the ever-rising (and unsustainable) cost of health care have begun to awaken the American public about the harms of overtreatment, Lenzer writes. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.