Newspaper article Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Pittsburgh, PA)

Figure on Losers Aplenty from Reassessment Mess

Newspaper article Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Pittsburgh, PA)

Figure on Losers Aplenty from Reassessment Mess

Article excerpt

It's the tax cut nobody believes in.

"Never has good news been so badly received," Chris Briem said of Allegheny County's massive reassessment of city real estate.

About six of every 10 property owners would see a tax cut out of these reassessments, Mr. Briem estimated, days before county Executive Rich Fitzgerald said he wasn't going to use them.

Common Pleas Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr. didn't waste any time responding with an order that says, in effect, that government by tantrum won't do. The city and school district must base their property tax rates and bills on the new 2012 values, though the judge will consider the school system's request to use the old assessments for one more year.

The idea that Mr. Fitzgerald just snatched a tax break from thousands of homeowners is so far off the prevailing talk show story line that most people don't even want to hear it. But Mr. Briem, a University of Pittsburgh economist, has no horse in this race. The increased assessment on his Bloomfield home was almost smack dab on the citywide average residential uptick of 46 percent.

So if the city, school district and county then readjusted property tax rates downward -- as they are required to do under Pennsylvania's anti-windfall law -- Mr. Briem likely would come out about even.

It's all the property owners whose assessments went up only 10 to 40 percent who have been rooked. They, and those whose assessments went down or stayed still, won't get the break that would have come from a slashing of property tax rates.

Those rates not only aren't moving, they're going up. Last month, Mr. Fitzgerald backed a county council plan to tack another mill on the county property tax rate. That will work out to an additional $100 owed annually on a $100,000 house, but that's been largely forgotten in what may be the biggest snafu in county government since, well, the last reassessment.

Our property tax system has been a carnival game stuck on "tilt" for almost a decade now. There's no uniformity in the base assessments the county has been using since 2002. That was proven in court by the property owners who have been shafted by the current numbers. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.