Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Why Ukraine Speaks of Civilization to Americans

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Why Ukraine Speaks of Civilization to Americans

Article excerpt

Ukraine's crisis is almost a year old, first triggered by its drive for close economic ties with Europe. After a democratic revolution in Kiev, a war that has left thousands dead, and now an uneasy truce, it is more evident why Russian leader Vladimir Putin reacted so harshly.

Ukraine has upset his project to expand "Russian civilization" to millions of Russian-speakers in nearby lands. "We will always defend ethnic Russians in Ukraine," said Mr. Putin in July.

His concept of a russkiy mir (Russian world) with no defined borders is based on two beliefs, both with historical roots but re- envisioned over the past decade by a few Russian intellectuals: One is that Russia is spiritually superior to a corrupt West; the other is that the state - meaning the Kremlin - controls this civilization.

Putin may have specific interests, such as keeping a naval base in the now-annexed Crimea and relying on Ukraine as a buffer state against a future invasion. But the animating spirit is his civilizing project. And it is reflected by Ukraine's pro-Russia separatists in their self-proclaimed "people's republics." They demand that the "space of the entire Ukraine-Russian civilization" be preserved.

The people in the West, however, hear about a different "civilization" at stake.

In a speech Thursday before the US Congress, Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko stated: "The choice is simple: It is between civilization and barbarism."

By civilization, Mr. Poroshenko means the need to honor territorial integrity, freedom, security agreements, rule of law, and other ideals. With the incursion of Russian troops into Ukraine, he says, "it is Europe's and it is America's war, too. It is a war for the free world."

How should the United States and Europe resolve this apparent "clash of civilizations"?

President Obama and German Chancellor Angela Merkel have taken a cautious approach, imposing sanctions on Russia but keeping an "offramp" available for Putin to leave Ukraine alone. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.