Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Israel Elections 101: Whiffs of 'It's the Housing Market, Stupid'

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Israel Elections 101: Whiffs of 'It's the Housing Market, Stupid'

Article excerpt

In the United States and other developed countries, rising home values are usually seen as a measure of economic health and prosperity and bode well for incumbents.

But in Israel recently, the steady advance of real estate prices has become a political albatross that could threaten Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in elections next month.

The Israeli leader is facing a public uproar after the state comptroller released a highly critical 294-page report Wednesday evening blaming his government for failing to spur enough housing construction to make up for a shortage of hundreds of thousands of apartments.

The result has been a 55 percent rise in real housing prices between 2008 and the end of 2014 that has squeezed middle- and lower- income Israelis.

One might expect that Israel's March 17 general election would be influenced more by Mr. Netanyahu's growing isolation over his policy toward the Palestinians or the unprecedented clash with the Obama administration over his planned address next Tuesday to Congress on Iran. But analysts say it's the Israeli prime minister's handling of economic issues and Israel's rising cost of living that is his biggest vulnerability.

"What is striking about this election is that everyone is focused internationally on Iran and Netanyahu-Obama, but if you look at surveys that assess the Israeli electorate's priorities, it's the economy, and the ability to get by," says David Horovitz, editor of the Times of Israel news website.

"It seems that economic issues are central to this election," he says, "and here's a report that's pretty damning about the Netanyahu government's failure to put into place more frameworks that would allow for more affordable housing."

Housing has been a charged issue on Israel's public agenda ever since a group of twenty-somethings pitched tents on a central Tel Aviv boulevard in the summer of 2011 to protest runaway rental prices. Eventually, hundreds of thousands of Israelis took to the streets in demonstrations that crossed political lines and focused on gripes that have put Netanyahu on the defensive over Israel's high cost of living ever since.

Four years later, the report echoed much of the protester's accusations of government neglect. Though it doesn't mention Netanyahu by name, the report faults his government for failing to identify the crisis for more than a year after taking office in 2009 and then for producing ineffective and unrealistic solutions.

Problems with Likud base"The housing crisis threatens the economic resilience of households and strikes a blow at their standard of living ... and there's a threat to the stability of the entire economy," the report said.

"The government and its ministries pursued a deficient national housing policy ... taking improvised and unplanned actions," it said. "Most of the decisions were never implemented or their implementation was delayed."

Many economists blame the housing crisis on the vestiges of Israel's socialist roots: The government owns 80 percent of the land in the country and monopolizes the real estate market. Planning processes are centralized, but mired in endless bureaucracy: the state comptroller's report said it takes 11 years for builders to obtain permits to begin construction.

The report potentially hits at a long-time trusted base for Netanyahu: Likud's moderate Sephardic working-class constituency, many of whom consider him a cold-hearted capitalist and elitist. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.