Newspaper article Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Pittsburgh, PA)

Nitrogen-Filled Tires Can Be Overrated

Newspaper article Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Pittsburgh, PA)

Nitrogen-Filled Tires Can Be Overrated

Article excerpt

Dear Car Talk:

My questions involve the nitrogen-filled tires on my 2011 Subaru Outback. These were on the car when I bought it, and I was assured that they had advantages over air-filled tires. But this was kind of a last-minute decision, and I confess I didn't do any research into the matter. My husband and I are snowbirds, and recently, just before leaving for Florida, I had a flat tire. This brought questions to mind, since not all garages are equipped with nitrogen: (1) Is it OK to drive a car with one air-filled tire and three nitrogen-filled tires, as suggested by the fellow who changed the tire? (2) Can existing nitrogen-filled tires be refilled with air? (3) Would it be more practical to just bite the bullet and buy four new air-filled tires? (I dread the expense!) My main concern is driving between North and South on the interstates and getting a flat, in the middle of nowhere, and not having access to a nitrogen supply. I'll look forward to your answer! -- Clem

Great questions, Clem. And the answer, as my brother would have said, is: fuggedaboutit.

I think the nitrogen-filled-tire thing is a scam. Obviously, as you were in the final hours of purchasing your new car, they sold you on a bunch of add-ons. You bit on the pinstripes, the pom-pom on the antenna in the shape of Vladimir Putin and the nitrogen- filled tires. And all that only added $30 to your monthly payment! Congratulations.

The argument they make is that the nitrogen doesn't contain oxygen, like normal air does. That's said to give you several advantages if you put it in your tires:

They say the oxygen in the air degrades the rubber more than nitrogen does. They say nitrogen molecules are slightly larger than oxygen molecules in the air, so it's less likely to leak through the rubber. They say if you use pure nitrogen from a tank, there's no water vapor in it, like there is in the air we breathe. Water vapor can affect pressure variation when the tires heat up, and can cause corrosion. And then some salesmen have claimed that if you have an accident and there's a fire, if your tires explode there won't be additional oxygen to further fuel the flames. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.