Newspaper article News Sentinel

Long Prison Terms Don't Deter Crime ; Experts: Fewer Prisoners Means Less Recidivism

Newspaper article News Sentinel

Long Prison Terms Don't Deter Crime ; Experts: Fewer Prisoners Means Less Recidivism

Article excerpt

NASHVILLE -- Sending someone to prison longer is no indication they'll be less likely to commit a crime once they're released, and longer sentences don't dissuade others from committing that crime, experts told lawmakers Monday.

In fact those legal and corrections experts said states that have reduced their prison populations the most have also seen a drop in the crime rate.

"Long sentences are not the panacea that many people think they are. They do not reduce crime, they do not increase public safety, and they cost the state a whole lot of money," said Professor Christopher Slobogin, director of the Criminal Justice Program at Vanderbilt University Law School.

"I think the common intuition, and it's a natural one, is 'hey, if we want to protect the public let's put them in as long as possible.' But in fact the data show, and I think theory suggests, it doesn't make sense to do that."

The debate comes as the administration of Gov. Bill Haslam and lawmakers look at reforming how offenders are sentenced, when they may be eligible to leave prison and what they need to do once they are released. Although Haslam and lawmakers haven't put forward any specific plans, advocates and experts are worried any proposal to change when prisoners are released could lead to people unnecessarily spending more time in prison.

Slobogin was one of six people to testify at a Senate Judiciary Committee meeting Monday after the state discussed the findings of a sentencing task force. Although Department of Safety and Homeland Security Commissioner Bill Gibbons read through the 16 recommendations, the majority of discussion focused on an idea to set a minimum amount of time served on a sentence.

Gibbons and others who testified acknowledged that under the current judicial system it's very hard to predict when someone will be released from prison. There is the length of a sentence, and what's known as a "release eligibility date," also called RED. For many offenses, that RED comes at 30 percent of a sentence; for a 10- year sentence, the RED could be three years.

However, any number of factors could move up or delay the RED, Gibbons noted, as inmates can earn credit for good behavior or taking classes, and generally get credit for any time served leading to their trial. The state is considering a number of solutions to try and provide some predictability as to when an inmate might actually get out of prison. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.