Newspaper article The Canadian Press

B.C. Government Releases Tech Contract after Eight-Year Legal Battle

Newspaper article The Canadian Press

B.C. Government Releases Tech Contract after Eight-Year Legal Battle

Article excerpt

B.C. releases contract after lengthy battle


VANCOUVER - The British Columbia government has begrudgingly released the unredacted version of a $300-million technology contract with IBM after spending more than $200,000 over nearly a decade fighting to keep the document hidden from the public.

The B.C. Freedom of Information and Privacy Association filed a freedom-of-information request for the contract after it was signed in December 2004, setting off a complex battle that spanned the careers of two premiers and nearly outlasted the agreement itself.

The Liberal government, which argued releasing the contract that covers computer support services would put the province's information systems at risk.

It suffered its latest loss last month when the B.C. Supreme Court upheld an order that the document must be released. Rather than appeal, the government posted the full, 535-page version of the agreement to its website this week.

The association's executive director, Vincent Gogolek, said the contract likely won't make it on most British Columbians' bedtime reading lists, but that the details of such agreements must be made public.

"If you're going to be transferring government services over to the private sector but still paying for them with public money, we should still be able to hold you accountable for that, and the minimum would be to get the terms under which these services would be provided," said Gogolek.

"It's a reflection of the culture of the government. The culture is, 'You can't have that,' and then they start looking around for reasons why not."

The 10-year contract expires in March 2015.

The provincial government and IBM have both made various arguments to explain why the contract should not be released in its entirety.

IBM argued sections of the contract would harm its financial interests if released, though the company's objections have since been resolved.

The government claimed information in the document could help hackers penetrate its systems, while also damaging the province's ability to negotiate in the future.

The province released a redacted version of the contract in 2010, with most of those redactions focusing on the names and physical locations of equipment and software, but the province's information and privacy commissioner ordered the government to release the contract with those details intact.

The province then asked the B.C. Supreme Court to intervene, but the court ruled last month that the government failed to prove any harm would come from releasing the full contract.

Gogolek said the case began when former premier Gordon Campbell was in office, but it continued even after Premier Christy Clark came to power promising a new era of openness and accountability.

"We've got an election coming up, people will have to look at the record of the government and this is part of that record," he said. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.