Newspaper article The Canadian Press

Changes at RIM's Board Could Only Cause More Upheaval, Experts Suggest

Newspaper article The Canadian Press

Changes at RIM's Board Could Only Cause More Upheaval, Experts Suggest

Article excerpt

Change at RIM's board: does it make sense?


TORONTO - For all the sound and fury, and calls for upheaval at Research In Motion's annual meeting this week, little has changed for the BlackBerry maker, which is still facing the make-or-break proposition to bring its new operating system to market.

Inside the meeting, at least one vocal shareholder pushed for a major shakeup of the company's board -- and even the resignation of CEO Thorsten Heins, who stepped into the role earlier this year.

As the dust settled around the event, it became clear that most shareholders weren't ready for such a significant change, even though a vote to re-elect the directors showed a notable level of dissatisfaction.

While shareholders did not vote down any of the board nominees, an increasing number chose to withhold their votes in a sign of dissent.

On Friday, the official tallies were released, showing that director John Richardson had 30.25 per cent of votes withheld, while Roger Martin, dean of the University of Toronto's Rotman School of Management had 22.69 per cent withheld.

Other board members also saw declining support: former co-CEO Mike Lazaridis had 19.12 per cent of votes withheld and chairwoman Barbara Stymiest had 23.16 per cent withheld. Heins saw 14.85 per cent of shareholders abstain.

But as the level of seemingly disgruntled shareholders rises, the key question is: would a massive makeover of RIM's board during its current strife make sense?

"Changing a number of the board members is not really going to get the new operating system developed any faster," said Colin Cieszynski, market analyst at CMC Markets Canada.

"Shareholders are very understandably angry ... (but) there's only so much they can do to influence a company."

Several shareholders have called for change at RIM, but none more vehemently than Vic Alboini of Jaguar Financial, who stepped to the microphone on Tuesday and presented a case similar to the one he has been making since last year.

At one time, he wanted co-CEOs Jim Balsillie and Lazaridis bumped from their positions, but after that shuffle happened in January, Alboini turned his sights to the board, including Heins.

"I think he should be gone from the company,'' Alboini said in an interview earlier this week. "He was there for the last five years and he was part of the problem."

Leaders at RIM have expressed their disagreement with Alboini in the past, and took a similar stance against comments he made earlier this week.

"Thorsten is more committed than ever to building long-term stakeholder value and is moving forward decisively to make the changes necessary for the future of RIM and BlackBerry," RIM spokesman Nick Manning said in an emailed statement.

"Mr. Alboini is entitled to his opinions and RIM has reviewed his proposals, but does not believe they have been advanced in the best interests of RIM or its stakeholders. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.