Newspaper article The Canadian Press

U.S. Exxon Lawsuit Takes Aim at Alberta Oilsands over Climate Risks

Newspaper article The Canadian Press

U.S. Exxon Lawsuit Takes Aim at Alberta Oilsands over Climate Risks

Article excerpt

U.S. Exxon lawsuit takes aim at Alberta oilsands


Energy companies are likely to face more lawsuits similar to one filed this week that alleges ExxonMobil dramatically underestimated the risks carbon regulations pose to its oilsands assets, a legal scholar says.

"There are actual cases being developed in Canada," said Cynthia Williams, a law professor at York University's Osgoode Hall who has written about climate liability.

"I would not be surprised if you see something within the next six months."

On Wednesday, New York's attorney general filed a fraud lawsuit against ExxonMobil alleging the company deliberately misled investors about the risks posed by carbon taxes and other measures designed to reduce oil use.

The lawsuit, which has not been tested in court, alleges the company told investors it made plans assuming carbon prices as high as $80 a tonne. In fact, says the lawsuit, Exxon was evaluating projects internally with a much lower price.

After a three-year investigation, the attorney general charges that Exxon lowballed the carbon costs of 14 Alberta oilsands operations it partly owns through subsidiary Imperial Oil by $30 billion. Court documents say carbon costs at the Kearl oilsands project were understated by 94 per cent.

Using low carbon costs also falsely extended the economic life of some assets, the lawsuit claims, adding the lifespan of Imperial's Cold Lake facility would be shortened by 28 years if evaluated with a true carbon price.

Exxon has said it will seek to have the lawsuit thrown out of court as baseless. It has said in its court filings that it uses several methods to price carbon risk into its decisions and that the lawsuit ignores most of them.

Industry experts have also said carbon risks are likely to fall in the oilsands as better technology reduces industry emissions.

Williams said CEOs will have to be increasingly careful to disclose how the fight against climate change may affect their businesses. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.