E-Mail, Voice Mail, and Instant Messaging: A Legal Perspective: An Organization That Uses Messaging Faces a Legal Landscape That Urges, If Not Demands, a Rational Policy for Managing Messaging Data
Montana, John C., Information Management
At the Core
* discusses e-mail voice mail and instant messaging as records from a legal perspective
* provides examples of messaging restrictions and guidelines in the United States and worldwide
* examines considerations for policies for managing messaging data
Since the early 1990s, e-mail has become ubiquitous worldwide, Many businesses are dependent on it. and a significant percentage of all private individuals in the developed world are equally dependent on it as a means--often a primary means--of communication with others, More recently, instant messaging (IM) has achieved a similar status. In many environments business and personal, it is an important communication tool. Lurking on the sidelines is still another widely used tool, voice messaging.
These tools pose formidable challenges in many respects. From a business and management perspective, their utility--often very high--is counterbalanced by their unstructured, inherently difficult-to-manage nature and the sheer volume of data that is transmitted and accumulated using them. From a legal perspective, their rapid acceptance, combined with the equally rapid changes in the technologies of which they are a part, makes it difficult for the often slow moving legal world to keep pace with them.
This confluence of factors poses several issues for the organization that uses these technologies extensively:
* Storage of large volumes of e-mail, voice mail, and IM imposes significant costs on an organization in terms of infrastructure and equipment, manpower, and other resources.
* The difficulties of managing millions--or even billions of informal data objects, created with little or no attention to formal structuring or indexing, make systematic management and recovery of them challenging and expensive.
* The e-mail so stored is subject to legal process, requiring searches that may prove difficult and expensive.
From a legal perspective, another group of issues arises:
* Are data objects created using these technologies "records"?
* If so, must they he formally managed?
* What retention period is appropriate for them?
* Are all these technologies the same legally, or do they fall into different classes?
These business and legal issues collectively pose a very formidable conundrum for any business or other large organization.
What Exactly Are E-mail, Voice Mail, and IM Legally?
From a management perspective, e-mail, voice mail, and IM (hereafter collectively called "messaging") as "non records" or legal non-entities would be the most convenient situation. An organization would therefore be free to manage or not manage them as it saw fit. Included in this approach would presumably be the option to establish an arbitrary retention period suited to the convenience and budget of the organization.
A good deal of law impacts messaging. Much of it is indirect in that it does not specifically refer to the technologies themselves. Nonetheless, it does have a direct impact on the way messaging must be managed. The ultimate sweep of that law is perhaps best characterized by an analysis of the United Nations Commission on International Trade (UNICTRAL) Model Law on Electronic Commerce, which serves as the basis for many national laws governing the topic.
According to UNICTRAL, "'Data message' means information generated, sent, received, or stored by electronic, optical, or similar means including, but not limited to, electronic data interchange (EDI), electronic mail, telegram, telex, or telecopy."
Consideration of this brief provision reveals that its scope is broad indeed: Messaging of all sorts, regardless of the technology, is a "data message" within the meaning of this law.
UNICTRAL also describes several legal attributes of a data message:
* "Information shall not be denied legal effect, validity, or enforceability solely on the grounds that it is in the form of a data message. …