Gender Matters in the Counseling Setting: Gender-Sensitive Treatment Can Enhance Women's Gains
Didham, Steve, Csiernik, Rick, Addiction Professional
Throughout history, differences between men and women have been explored with a diversity of opinions postulated. It should come as no surprise, then, that this area of inquiry would arise in the addiction field, as well. Addiction is a biopsychosocial phenomenon, and distinctions between women and men exist in all three of these realms.
The addiction treatment system in North America was created predominantly by men for men, but researchers, consumers, and practitioners all indicate that treatment factors differ for men and women, and that women are more likely to experience difficulty in navigating the system. (1) Still, surprisingly little research has looked into the implications of gender for treatment programs. It has been reported, however, that women tend to have greater problems than men prior to treatment, such as greater psychological distress, more medical problems, and more family and social difficulties. (2,3)
Yet several studies have indicated that women fare just as well as men in formal substance abuse treatment. For example, no gender differences were noted when studying substance abuse clients with posttraumatic stress disorder. (4) The use of coping strategies after treatment has been linked to improved relapse prevention for both sexes. (5) And researchers have found no significant gender differences in relapse rates or effort toward recovery. (6)
However, research has uncovered significant differences between the sexes with respect to the process of treatment. It has been documented that during the initial stages of counseling, women will attend a greater proportion of required sessions and will tend to focus more on crisis intervention, personal issues, and conflict. Men, on the other hand, are typically more concerned with their actual use of substances and with legal issues arising from their use. (7)
Women also remain at greater risk of relapse than do men for a variety of reasons. Because women tend to obtain more social support from friends than do men, they may find themselves more often in situations in which they feel pressured into substance use when with these friends, to reciprocate the support. Also, relapse risk is exacerbated when women are in the regular presence of a romantic partner. (8) Research has indicated that male partners do not supply the same level of mutual aid and support during and posttreatment that female partners do, and male partners also are more likely to continue their own substance use after the woman's treatment.
Women's coping abilities
Csiernik and Troller conducted an evaluation of a community-based agency's mixed-gender relapse-prevention program using the 36-item Coping Behaviours Inventory to assess clients' coping strategies in response to the urge to drink or use drugs. (9) The closed relapse-prevention group had eight consecutive weekly sessions with a cognitive-behavioral focus. Clients were supported if they had a slip or full-blown relapse while enrolled in the group; in return, they were expected to be honest in discussing the circumstances that led to using again and what alternative actions would be taken in the future.
Csiernik and Troller found that clients almost immediately used the relapse-prevention strategies taught to them during group counseling. Clients who completed counseling continued to increase the number and range of alternative coping behaviors two and six months posttreatment, with nearly a 20% change between pretreatment and six-month posttreatment scores. However, when conducting a gender analysis, the researchers discovered that much of the overall group success was a result of significant increases in women's coping strategies and abilities.
There had been a minimal difference in pretest scores between men and women. While the men were doing slightly better six months after counseling, the women's improvement was statistically significant. …