Gender Differences in the Expression of Depressive Symptoms in Middle Adolescents: An Extension of Earlier Findings
Baron, Pierre, Campbell, T. Leanne, Adolescence
Epidemiological studies in Western culture consistently report a higher rate of unipolar depression for females than males (e.g., Baron & Perron, 1986; Nolen-Hoeksema, 1987). Based on research demonstrating that expression of depressive symptomatology elicits interpersonal rejection (e.g., Coyne, 1976), especially for males (Hammen & Peters, 1977), and that individuals view depression as more stereotypically feminine (Landrine, 1988), researchers have argued that depression may be more socially unacceptable for males than it is for females (Warren, 1983). Consequently, individuals may learn to express their psychological distress in gender-appropriate ways.
Baron and Joly (1988) identified gender differences in the expression of depressive symptoms in a sample of adolescents (aged 12 through 17 years) scoring 15 or more on the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI; Beck, Ward, Mendelson, Mock, & Erbaugh, 1961). Discriminant function analyses revealed that male adolescents exhibited symptoms of irritability, work inhibition, social withdrawal, and sleep disturbance, whereas females manifested symptoms characterized by body image distortion, loss of appetite, weight loss, sadness, and dissatisfaction. Similarly, gender-role appropriate symptom expression was found in a sample of clinically depressed adult clients (Vredenburg, Krames, & Flett, 1986), and in depressed subsamples of college students (e.g., Hammen & Padesky, 1977; Padesky & Hammen, 1981). In contrast, Campbell, Byrne, and Baron (1992) found that females had higher mean scores on all of the BDI and the Reynolds Adolescent Depression Scale (RADS; Reynolds, 1986) items that significantly discriminated between male and female nonclinical early adolescents.
The present study contributes to the body of research aimed at examining the expression of depressive symptoms in adult and adolescent clinical and nonclinical samples. The purpose of the study was to examine whether, consistent with the findings based on data obtained at the first phase of the longitudinal study, females continue to have higher mean scores on all discriminating items as mid-adolescence is approached. Unlike previous research, the present study investigates gender differences in the expression of depressive symptoms among the same nonclinical sample over time. This design permits a description of normative patterns in the expression of depressive symptoms, and facilitates the understanding and interpretation of depression scale scores for males and females in other clinical and nonclinical samples.
Sample and Procedure
Data were derived from a larger longitudinal study aimed at examining the prevalence of depressive symptoms in francophone adolescents (Baron & Groulx, 1990; Baron, Regimbald, & Groulx, 1991). Participants were assessed at two time points, approximately one year apart. Data for this study were obtained from a total of 153 subjects (98 females, 55 males) aged 14 through 16 years (M = 14.9 years). Informed consent was obtained, and subjects were ensured of confidentiality. Testing took place in the context of intact classes using translated versions of the BDI (Baron & LaPlante, 1984) and the RADS (Baron & DeChamplain, 1990) as two of several instruments.
Beck Depression Inventory. The BDI is a 21-item self-report scale presented in multiple-choice format. Developed to measure depth of clinical depression, it assesses symptoms related to cognitive, affective, behavioral, and somatic components of depression (Beck et al., 1961). Each item on the inventory corresponds with one of these symptoms, and numerical values ranging from zero to three are assigned to each of four statements to indicate degree of severity. Subjects are asked to describe the way they have been feeling for the past week. Total scores range from 0 to 63, with higher scores indicative of greater severity of self-reported depression. …