ABA: Banks Can Benefit from Safety Measures at ATMs
Barthel, Matt, American Banker
A report from the American Bankers Association asserts that the automated teller machine safety measures reluctantly being installed by many financial institutions are not without benefits to the banks.
The report, entitled "ATM Security," summarizes the state of ATM safety -- including the status of various legislative efforts -- in the United States.
The issue has been a growing concern to bankers, as ATM crimes and the attention given them by the media have both risen in recent years.
The ABA report acknowledges that ATM crime is a serious problem.
However, the statistics it contains also suggest that there is no need for bankers to panic.
According to numbers gathered by the ABA in the late 1980s, less than one ATM transaction in a million results in a robbery or assault against the customer making the transaction.
This estimate is considered conservative by at least one ATM security expert who maintains that the actual rate of crime was -- and remains closer to -- one for every three million transactions.
"Over the last few years, the number of ATM crimes has risen, but the number of total ATM transactions has risen right along with it. As a result, the rate of ATM crime has stayed fairly level." said Barry Schreiber, a criminal justice professor at St. Cloud State University in Minnesota.
Mr. Schreiber, who publishes an ATM security newsletter, noted further that some areas of the country experience more crime than others.
In California, for instance, one in 1.2 million ATM transactions is affected by a crime, according to 1993 figures from the California Bankers Association.
New York and several southern states have similarly high ATM crime rates.
ATM users in the Midwest appear to be much less likely to be robbed or assaulted at an ATM, Mr. Schreiber and other observers said.
The ABA report asserts that ATM crime -- like regular street muggings -- is not necessarily preventable.
"Irrational behavior (such as that which occurs in a crime driven by the needs of chug addiction) is seldom influenced by rational deterrents, such as security cameras, jail time, or other penalties," the report said. …