Anti-Americanism, Anti-Westernism, and Anti-Semitism among Russia's Muslims
Hahn, Gordon, Demokratizatsiya
Abstract: An expression of much of the Islamic world's clash with Western civilization is its anti-Americanism, anti-Westernism, anti-Semitism, and Islamic solidarity. Russia's Muslims are no exception. Many in the West regard Samuel Huntington's "clash of civilizations" as absurd and Russia's Caucasus militants as representing a noble national liberation movement tightly seeking their separation from an imperial or colonial power, as they have for centuries. Russia's more traditional Muslims express the same limited and prejudiced range of opinions toward the West that many Muslims around the world do, writ large. More ominously, the global jihadist element is beginning to hold sway over the Caucasus Islamist militants. As a result, Russia's Caucasus jihad reflects much of the rabid anti-Americanism, anti-Westernism, anti-Semitism, and Islamist solidarity that jihadists across the globe espouse.
Keywords: anti-Americanism, anti-Semitism, anti-Westernism, Islam, jihadists, terrorism
Although many in the West do not subscribe to Samuel Huntington's view regarding a "clash of civilizations," many of the world's Muslims and all Islamists do. An expression of the Islamic world's clash with Western
civilization is its rabid anti-Americanism, anti-Westernism, anti-Semitism, and Islamic solidarity. Russia's Muslims are no exception. They express the same limited and prejudiced range of opinions that many Muslims around the world do toward the West. Despite this, some in the West persist in believing that even Russia's most extremist Muslims--the North Caucasus jihadists led by the Chechen hub calling itself the Chechen Republic of Ichkeriya (ChRI)--are neither jihadists nor militants. (1) Many analysts believe the Caucasus militants compose a noble national liberation movement rightly seeking their separation from an imperial or colonial power, as they have for centuries. (2) They scrupulously and relentlessly subject Russian actions to microscopic analysis and harsh criticism, but largely ignore and routinely abstain from criticizing the Caucasus jihadists' means, methods, and ideology. (3)
In fact, the Islamist element has held sway over the Chechen militants since the summer of 2002. Islamists Shamil Basayev and Shariah Court Chairman Abdul-Khalim Sadulayev forced President Asian Maskhadov to amend the ChRI constitution, subordinating him and the constitution to Shariah law as interpreted by Chechen and other Caucasus jihadists. The Chechen separatist movement expanded the war to the wider North Caucasus region and aimed to expand it to all of Russia's "Muslim lands" to establish an Islamic state or federation of Islamic states. The Caucasus jihad adopted the global jihadist tactics of suicide bombing and improvised explosive devices. Ideological declarations were increasingly Salafist Islamist in character, championing Shariah law, martyrdom, Islamic caliphates, and anti-infidelism over Chechen or Caucasus nationalism and independence, anticolonialism, and anti-Russian elements. (4)
I will examine anti-Americanism, anti-Westernism, and anti-Semitism--all of which for purposes of brevity I refer to at times as anti-infidelism--among Russia's various Muslim orientations as reflected in the jihadists' and the moderate Muslim elite's discourses on global affairs. Anti-American messages from the outside Muslim world, Russia's Islamic media and elite, and non-Islamic Russian media are among the factors that foster such sentiments among Russia's Muslims. I focus on Muslim articulations because Western media and think tanks have covered anti-infidelism extensively, while coverage of Russia's Muslims has been nonexistent. The Islamic political elite, as the Muslims' leadership and as potential and kinetic ethnoconfessional entrepreneurs, are of pivotal importance for the direction that many of Russia's re-Islamizing ethnic Muslims might take in the future, particularly in relation to jihad against Russian or other infidels. …