Carlozo, Louis R., The Christian Century
It's been some time since I donned my best professional earbuds to focus on a question of audio fidelity. But the band in question is the Beatles and the discs part of an ambitious remastering of the band's catalog. Remastered Beatles material is as controversial as restoring a DaVinci--does the cleanup forever change the way the art will be perceived?
Of course it does. But in this case, even the $260 16-disc stereo box set (plus DVD) and $299 13-disc mono box set won't give you a definitive listening experience. Remastering Beatles material for ordinary CD is the sonic equivalent of taking that improved fidelity and clarity and then squeezing it into a straw. Compare that to Super Audio CDs, developed in 1999 but still waiting to catch on. Super Audio represents a huge improvement in quality that you don't have to be a hi-fi geek to notice: it sounds amazing, as if you're sitting in the Studio 2 control room with the Fabs, listening to the playback of Revolver.
As for these remastered Beatles CDs, while no match for a great vinyl copy of your favorite album, they do yield a boost in quality. The rock tunes in particular benefit from all the sonic flossing. On "I'm Down," the ambient reverb cushioning Paul McCartney's voice gleams, and everything growling in the rhythm shakes and shimmies with added snarl. "Drive My Car" also sounds as if remixed afresh, a formerly indistinguishable piano rift popping out on the song's fadeout.
Yet the remastering isn't always a net gain. "And Your Bird Can Sing," while clearer in the upper register, doesn't sound as cohesive in its newly minted form. Likewise, on "I Am the Walrus," McCartney's bass just doesn't break out of the gate the way it does on previous versions. In the audio realm, cleaner doesn't always equal better.
As an audio engineer, critic and Beatles lover, I'd suggest not spending money on these box sets. Consider that in the remastering, the Beatles brain trust prepared the new results for a possible Blu-Ray audio release. Once these versions become available, I expect they'll merit replacing every disc in your catalog. Until then, I'll enjoy the Beatles recordings I currently own, especially the bootlegs--most of which are of marginal sound quality yet reveal incredible musical treats. In the final analysis, the songs always matter far more than sonic purity.
Time Stands Still by Chris Smither (Signature Sounds). Folk.
Chris Smither picks and growls with the best of them. Here he mixes blues, folk and tinges of country to create a sepia-tone soundscape that makes for prime wintertime listening. The title track bounds with brushed snare, foot-tapping and jangling acoustic guitar arpeggios. …