Churches Weigh in on Health-Care Reform
Dart, John, The Christian Century
United Methodists serving in the House of Representatives opposed the historic passage of the health-care reform package 26 to 18, with five Democrats joining 21 Republicans in voting no.
Yet, in remarks just before the March 21 vote, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi cited the United Methodist Church as one of the many organizations "sending a clear message to members of Congress" asking them to vote yes.
Pelosi's Web site also listed groups that backed reform, and it included the UMC's Board of Church and Society, whose chief executive is James Winkler.
Winkler noted that the United Methodist documents declare health care for all "a basic human fight" and believe it "a governmental responsibility," according to United Methodist News Service. Gregory Palmer, president of the Council of Bishops, said he "rejoiced" at the bill's passage because it aligns with Methodist values.
The Methodists' top legislative assembly, which meets at four-year intervals, took no stand on health-care reform at its 2008 General Conference. But delegates did charge the Board of Church and Society with the primary responsibility for advocating for universal health care. The church's 2008 book of resolutions observed that "fulfillment of this duty is thwarted by simultaneous crises of access, quality and cost."
The nearly $1 trillion price tag for the bill drew heated objections from Republicans, who also opposed expanded federal regulation. After the bill was passed by a 219-212 vote, President Obama signed the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act into law on March 23. The GOP has promised to seek repeal of the law and to challenge it in courts.
While the different opinions of United Methodists on the legislation did not become a public issue, disputes among Roman Catholics were highly visible.
The U.S. Catholic Conference of Bishops contended that the legislation was flawed because it "expands federal funding and the role of the federal government in the provision of abortion procedures," in the words of Cardinal Francis George of Chicago.
But a yes vote was sought by Sister Carol Keehan, president and CEO of the Catholic Health Association, which represents about 2,000 Catholic health-care facilities and organizations. She approved the antiabortion language in the Senate version and termed passage of the bill a "moral imperative. …