Feds Wondered Who Funded Push to Probe Google; Watchdog Says It Took No Money from Rivals
Byline: Jim McElhatton, THE WASHINGTON TIMES
The chairman of the Federal Trade Commission and a top FTC staffer traded emails in 2010 about whether Facebook and other tech companies were secretly funding a nonprofit group pushing hard for regulators to investigate Google Inc.
The messages, revealed in internal emails recently obtained by The Washington Times through the Freedom of Information Act, were exchanged as the FTC was being asked by the California-based group Consumer Watchdog to investigate Google's Street View mapping project. The project came under scrutiny after Google said it had mistakenly harvested personal data from homeowners' unsecured wireless networks.
The FTC correspondence centered on a May 18, 2010, report by the Wall Street Journal, FTC Likely to Examine Google's Wireless Gaffe, which noted how Consumer Watchdog called on the FTC to launch a probe. The article prompted Cecelia Prewett, director of the FTC's public affairs office, to send an email to colleagues asking, Who's feeding him?
Robert Davis, then an attorney adviser with the FTC who is now in private practice, responded, Could it be Google feeding him here? Might they want to say that the FTC is looking at this so the Europeans should wait and see (and maybe calm down)? Just another diabolical press theory.
Ms. Prewett, in a subsequent email, added, [It's] also Microsoft and Yahoo which probably funds the consumer group making the complaint.
Hours later, FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz responded, and maybe Facebook - one of the folks who works for them sent it to me.
An official with Consumer Watchdog, which has been a frequent and sharp critic of Google, said despite the speculation, the organization does not receive funding from the search engine's competitors - Microsoft, Yahoo or Facebook.
I don't know why they would have speculated about that, said John M. Simpson, privacy director for Consumer Watchdog. They could have just called and asked.
He said the group had an opportunity to take funding from a Google competitor but decided against it.
The organization's funding, he said, comes from a mix of fundraising and grant sources, including from the Rose Foundation. That's the same organization to which a Google official wrote in 2009 complaining about Consumer Watchdog, though the official later apologized for the letter. …