Exception to Birth Control Ban Raises Questions
Allen, John L. JR., National Catholic Reporter
A Spanish bishop raised eyebrows in late January by stating that religious women living in war zones or other places where there is danger of rape can legitimately use oral contraceptives to protect themselves from pregnancy.
Despite skeptical reactions from some quarters, one of Rome's foremost Catholic moral theologians says the bishop did nothing more than re-state official church policy that dates back at least 40 years.
The Catholic church generally bans the use of contraceptives on the grounds that human sexuality should be "open" to the creation of life.
Despite that position, Bishop Juan Antonio Reig Pla of Segorbe-Castellon said in late January that sisters who face a danger of rape, such as missionaries in war zones, may use the pill as "self-defense against an act of aggression," according to the Madrid-based newspaper El Pais.
Reig, president of the Family and Life subcommittee of the Spanish bishops' conference, was speaking at a news conference to promote a Feb. 4 "day in defense of life."
Reig said use of contraception by religious women as a defense against rape "changes the nature of the moral act," rendering it no longer an illicit attempt to "go against conception." Reig declined, according to the report, to say whether other Catholic women should be able to use birth control in the same context.
Media outlets around the world immediately began asking church officials for comment, in most cases eliciting dubious responses.
A spokesperson for the Irish bishops, for example, told a reporter, "As far as we're concerned, there has been no dispensation given by the Vatican. And until we hear differently, we'll continue to follow the official line, which is the Catholic church officially forbids artificial contraception."
A spokesperson for the Vatican press office told the London Daily Telegraph that there is no "official dispensation" for nuns.
Yet Redemptorist Fr. Brian Johnstone, an expert in moral theology at Rome's prestigious Alphonsiana Academy, told NCR that in the early 1960s, the Vatican gave permission for religious women in the Belgian Congo to use contraceptives as a defense against rape.
"It was seen as a protection against pregnancy arising from unwanted, unfree sexual intercourse," Johnstone said.
Referring to Humanae Vitae, the 1968 document of Pope Paul VI that reiterated the church ban on birth control, Johnstone said the document "prohibits the inhibition of procreation in the context of free sexual intercourse. …