Distrusting Educational 'Accountability' No Test or Spreadsheet Can Capture Whether My Daughter's Love Of
Shervais, Marie, The Christian Science Monitor
The school my second-grade daughter goes to is right around the corner from our house. It is red brick, with big picture windows, and a bell on top. Every day I pick her up at 3 o'clock and see the flood of children run out onto the playground - a real playground, with grass and trees and crossing guards who know my child by name. I've planned for these days for years: Like almost everyone we know, we bought our house because it was in this school district.
But my husband and I, like many of our friends, are spending this spring looking at private schools. We're not looking because the academic scores in our neighborhood school have dropped, or because there are guns in the cafeteria - we're looking because we fear for our children's spirits. The doctrine of accountability, which everyone from President Clinton to Elizabeth Dole seems to be preaching, with its emphasis on testing and scores and layers of evaluation, is tearing at the heart of American education.
Accountability, in the broad sense, means that the quality of teachers and schools is measured by students' performance on standardized achievement tests. Schools with good scores are rewarded; schools with bad scores are punished, and in some states, closed down completely. Teachers and principals are held accountable for these test scores - so there's a lot of motivation for kids to do well on standardized tests. Maybe too much motivation: In Texas, a rising star in educational accountability, administrators from the Austin City School District were indicted earlier this month on charges of tampering with their students' test scores. The driving force behind the accountability stampede seems to be mainly legislators. Last year in South Carolina, the General Assembly passed the Education Accountability Act, mandating a new statewide test for grades 3 to 8. When the state's lead newspaper invited the legislators to take the test, not a single member was willing to take the risk. But these are the leaders who determine what will be taught in my daughter's classroom and how it will be taught. In the current political environment, where control is shifting from the classroom to the statehouse, or even the White House, the piece that we are leaving behind is education. Somehow we're forgetting that this is all about teaching children to use their minds, to reason, to discover. There's just no time for that anymore - we're too busy testing. I was gifted with a child who loves to learn, and if she can hold on to that, she can learn anything. I know absolutely that a huge component of teaching is intangible and cannot be measured, no matter how much you pay a consultant. This is the piece that keeps the love of learning alive in my child. …