Court Rejects Reverse Age Discrimination ; It Says a Federal Law Meant to Protect Older Workers Can't Be Used by the Young to Get Preferential Treatment
Warren Richey writer of The Christian Science Monitor, The Christian Science Monitor
Employers may use age as a valid criterion to award more lucrative benefits to older workers without violating the Age Discrimination in Employment Act.
In an important age-bias case, the US Supreme Court Tuesday sided with older workers in ruling that the ADEA does not empower relatively younger workers to file so-called reverse-discrimination lawsuits.
Instead, in 6-to-3 decision, the court said the law was intended to protect older workers from workplace discrimination that favors younger workers.
"If Congress had been worrying about protecting the younger against the older, it would not likely have ignored everyone under 40," writes Justice David Souter for the majority.
The decision is significant because it upholds the continued use of age as a valid triggering mechanism in early-retirement incentive plans and retirement packages negotiated through collective bargaining agreements. Such packages often use age as a means to apportion more lucrative benefits based on the advancing age of each worker.
The ADEA outlaws age-based discrimination in the workplace against any worker 40 or older. Some 70 million workers - about half the nation'sworkforce - are 40 or older.
At issue in the case was how that prohibition should apply to alleged age discrimination among workers who were all at least 40 years old, and thus covered by the protections of the ADEA. More precisely, the question was whether the ADEA bars any use of age as a criterion for special treatment in the workplace. If so, it would permit so-called reverse-discrimination lawsuits by younger workers challenging retirement incentive plans that offer more lucrative benefits to older workers based on their age.
Some analysts argued that the high court has sustained similar reverse-discrimination interpretations of civil rights statutes. …