Two Accounts of the Roosevelts: Wartime and Personal Portrayals
Keith Henderson. Keith Henderson is on the Monitor ., The Christian Science Monitor
Doris Kearns Goodwin, a historian known for previous work on Lyndon Johnson and on the Kennedys, examines the years just before and during World War II when Franklin Delano Roosevelt reached the pinnacle of his power. At the same time, Eleanor, who had diligently carved out a public persona of her own, sought new outlets for her energies as the domestic issues that had seized her attention receded before the onrush of battle.
Despite its tight focus, "No Ordinary Time: Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt: The Home Front in World War II" leaves a kaleidoscopic impression, thanks to Goodwin's extraordinary grasp of issues and people. Major themes, like FDR's struggle to push his isolationist nation toward a war even before a formal declaration of hostilities, shift into vivid patterns of subplots. These range from Eleanor's passion for civil rights, to sketches of Roosevelt intimates like Harry Hopkins, Missy LeHand, or Lorena Hickok.
The central relationship between the wartime president and his irrepressible wife drives the book. In contrast to Peter Collier's book, "The Roosevelts: An American Saga," which emphasizes the bitterness and alienation in Eleanor's relationship with FDR, Goodwin portrays a close and respectful partnership - though one strained by Franklin's earlier marital infidelity and Eleanor's independence.
While Eleanor's moral crusades could nettle FDR, who had little patience for them as war neared, her services could be indispensable - such as the unifying speech she delivered as Franklin's surrogate at the 1940 Democratic nominating convention, which chose FDR by acclaim despite deep reservations about breaking the two-term tradition.
When war came, Eleanor still could exert influence on occasion, as in the fights to break down, at least partially, the barriers preventing blacks from serving in the Navy or getting access to housing for defense workers. But when it came to the most blatant act of discrimination during the war years - the forced internment of thousands of Japanese-Americans - Eleanor could only register her moral shock. …