Beijing's Behavior Tests Resolve of US to Apply Sanctions Historically, the White House Has Often Put US Commerce above Other Strategic Interests
George Moffett, writer of The Christian Science Monitor, The Christian Science Monitor
SINCE the founding of the Republic - with rare exceptions - American presidents have put foreign trade above other strategic interests. Now China is putting that historic truism to one of its toughest tests.
Over the past two years China has sold nuclear technology to Pakistan, sent missiles to Iran, pirated US intellectual property, ignored demands to improve its human-rights record, and threatened Taiwan, one of the United States's most important trading partners.
But Mr. Clinton has hesitated to respond with punitive sanctions. China represents one of the world's most promising markets. US companies have pumped more than $20 billion into the country since 1990, building factories and offices. Given the link between markets abroad and jobs at home, some analysts say, restraint may be the only real option the president has. "American economic and diplomatic interests have usually gone hand-in-hand," says University of Connecticut diplomatic historian Thomas Paterson. But Clinton is feeling pressure. China's most-favored-nation trade status is up for renewal in June, and administration officials will face stiff opposition from Sen. Jesse Helms (R) of North Carolina and other members of Congress upset over China's recent behavior. One possible solution for the Clinton administration: targeted sanctions against particular Chinese companies, such as the firm suspected of aiding Pakistan's nuclear program. "Renewal of mostfavored-nation trade status does not mean you are not going to take strong and aggressive action in a particular area," Commerce Secretary Ron Brown said recently. In recent decades, economic as well as strategic considerations prompted the US to keep trade lines open to dictators from the Philippines to the Dominican Republic. Criticism of political corruption in Mexico, to choose another example, has been muted because of its evolving economic partnership with the US. In China, where rapid economic growth and a huge middle-class market have drawn hundreds of billions in foreign investment, the risks of punishing Beijing for human-rights violations and illegal arms sales are inordinately high. Number of US jobs tied to China US trade with China supports more than 200,000 American jobs plus additional employment in US ports, retail establishments, and consumer goods companies, according to the Business Coalition for US-China Trade, an association lobbying to keep Congress from revoking China's most-favored-nation trade status. In a rare recent exception to the rule that business considerations take precedence in foreign policy-making, Congress and the administration agreed to tighten sanctions on Cuba over the objections of US businesses. They complain that the US policy of isolating Cuba has kept them out of an opening multimillion-dollar market that companies from other nations are now cashing in on. The difference has been the Cuban-American lobby, whose political clout has served to offset the influence of the US business community. "Where you find this kind of domestic political power, it can force a break in the cooperation between the government and the business community," notes Cornell University diplomatic historian Walter LaFeber. …