Europe: The Struggle for Supremacy, 1453 to the Present: Books
Morgan, Roger, The Times Higher Education Supplement : THE
Europe: The Struggle for Supremacy, 1453 to the Present By Brendan Simms Allen Lane, 720pp, Pounds 30.00 and Pounds 17.99 ISBN 9780713994278 and 9781846147258 (e-book) Published 4 April 2013
Anyone not clear about the distinction between "diplomatic" and "international" history might compare Brendan Simms' exciting book with one bearing a similar title, The Struggle for Mastery in Europe, 1848- 1918, by A.J.P. Taylor, published in 1954. Taylor's is a masterpiece of diplomatic history: although he pays due attention to the fluctuating strengths and weaknesses of the European powers, his main focus is on the moves of statesmen on the diplomatic chessboard. Simms' kind of international history is much broader in scope. In his survey of European power politics through six centuries and more, he dissects the economic, social, administrative and religious aspects of the "domestic" life of the states involved, and shows that "domestic" and "foreign" affairs often make sense only when considered together. He quotes a dictum by William Gladstone that Michael Gove ought to ponder: "History is European ... it is unintelligible if treated as merely local."
Thus not only the economic and geopolitical but also the constitutional and religious concerns of 16th-century Spain are linked here with the phenomenon once memorably described by the A-level examinee who wrote that "the silver of the New World was flooding into the coiffeurs of Spain". Simms' eye for the telling detail is shown, for instance, in his contrast between the use made of Silesia before 1740, when it belonged to Austria, and after that year, when it was annexed by Prussia. Whereas Austria, a declining and incompetent state, could support only two cavalry regiments from Silesia's resources, the up-and-coming state of Prussia was able to organise them to support its entire army.
Through all the cycles of the rise and fall of a dominant power - 16th- century Spain, France under Louis XIV or Napoleon, or the Kaiser's Germany - Simms shows how both winners and losers were preoccupied, more or less effectively, with enhancing their economic capacity and administrative efficiency in order to withstand external pressure, or to exert it. Sometimes the domestic changes were revolutionary: both the English Civil War of the 1640s and the "Glorious Revolution" of 1688 had their roots in a perceived need for an English ruler willing to resist the rising power of France. Simms even argues, plausibly, that Britain's repeal of the Corn Laws in 1846 was motivated largely by Richard Cobden's "foreign policy" aim of making states more interdependent and thus less prone to conflict. …