Never Mind, Newt
York, Bryon, The American Spectator
REMEMBER NEWT GINGRICH'S COLLEGE COURSE? THE ONE HIS ENEMIES CALLED A TAX SCAM? NOW THAT THE IRS HAS CLEARED HIM, WILL THOSE ENEMIES ADMIT THEY WERE WRONG? NO WAY. BUT GINGRICH COULD STILL HAVE THE LAST LAUGH.
It was a few days before Christmas 1996, and David Bonior was not in the holiday spirit. With a characteristically grim look on his face, the Michigan Democrat walked into the House Radio-TV gallery to express his outrage at the ethical transgressions of Speaker Newt Gingrich. "Anyone who has engaged in seven years of tax fraud to further his own personal and political benefits is not deserving of the speakership," Bonior told reporters. "Mr. Gingrich has engaged in a pattern of tax fraud, lies, and cover-ups in paving his road to the second highest office in the land."
As he had several times since the Republican takeover of the House, Bonior called on the speaker to resign immediately. But he said whatever Gingrich might do, the issue would inevitably move beyond the House Ethics Committee, which was then conducting a long-running investigation. "I would expect the Justice Department, the FBI, a grand jury, and other appropriate entities to investigate," Bonior said. "I don't see any way they can ignore this." In the end, he predicted, the speaker would likely face criminal charges.
Bonior wasn't alone in making such allegations. Fellow Democrat John Lewis accused Gingrich of engaging in a "massive tax-fraud scheme." George Miller of California said his actions were designed "to defraud the tax laws of the country." And Colorado's Pat Schroeder concluded, "We might as well rip up all the laws, rip up all the rule books, if the guy at the head can thumb his nose at them."
At the center of the controversy was a course Gingrich taught from 1993 to 1995 at two small Georgia colleges. The class, called "Renewing American Civilization," was conceived by Gingrich and financed by a tax-exempt organization called the Progress and Freedom Foundation. Gingrich maintained that the course was a legitimate educational enterprise; his enemies contended that it had little to do with learning and was in fact a political exercise in which Gingrich abused a taxpayer-subsidized foundation to spread his own partisan message.
The accusation, started by a small group of Democrats but amplified in thousands of press reports, led to the Ethics Committee investigation, which in turn led Gingrich to make a limited confession of wrongdoing in January 1997. The speaker pleaded guilty to the previously unknown offense of failing to seek detailed advice from a tax lawyer before proceeding with the course, and he also admitted that he had provided "inaccurate, incomplete, and unreliable" information to Ethics Committee investigators. In return, the House reprimanded Gingrich and levied an unprecedented $300,ooo fine.
But the matter didn't end there. As David Bonior had hoped another government agency-the Internal Revenue Servicebegan an investigation of Gingrich. During a probe that took three years, the IRS carefully combed through the records of the college course, the workings of the Progress and Freedom Foundation, and the ways in which both related to Gingrich's political network. After finishing the investigation early this year, the IRS sent the foundation a densely written, highly detailed 74-page report which reached this conclusion: Gingrich acted completely within the law. There was no massive tax-fraud scheme.
Of course, by that time no one could undo the damage to Gingrich; he was out of Congress, widely assumed to be guilty, and $3co,ooo poorer after paying the fine with his own money. The report's main value appeared to be as a correction of the historical record.
But it might ultimately be more than that. At some point in the not-too-distant future, the IRS investigation could become a key element of Gingrich's rehabilitation. For a variety of reasons-among them his unstoppable stream of big ideas and his unmatched ability to raise large sums of money-Gingrich might well return to the front ranks of the Republican Party. …