Clinton versus Cleveland and Coolidge on Taxes
Reed, Lawrence W., Freeman
In a post-State of the Union speech in Buffalo, New York, on January 20, 1999, President William Jefferson Clinton was asked why Americans shouldn't get a tax cut since the federal budget is in surplus and the share of personal income taken by the federal government is at a post-World War II high. Is this what he said in response?
When more of the people's sustenance is exacted through the form of taxation than is necessary to meet the just obligations of government and the expense of its economical administration, such exaction becomes ruthless extortion and a violation of the fundamental principles of a free government.
No, unfortunately, Bill Clinton didn't say that-but how refreshing it would have. been if he had! Another Democratic president of long ago, Grover Cleveland (who, ironically, got his start in politics in Buffalo) said it in his second annual message to Congress in December 1886. What Bill Clinton did say was this:
"We could give it all back to you and hope you spend it right."
He went on to say he wanted to keep the surplus for such government programs as Social Security, and he concluded by tossing a question back to the audience: "I want every parent here to look at the young people here and ask yourself, `Do you really want to run the risk of squandering this surplus?' "
Bill Clinton is not the only American president who couldn't trust the people with their own money. Nor is Grover Cleveland the only president among the 41 we've had who wanted the people to keep more of what they earned. Clinton's audacious remarks harshly contrast with the perspective of another chief executive more recent than Cleveland: Calvin Coolidge. "Silent Cal" is one of my favorites and a man who would undoubtedly spurn Clinton as a mouthpiece for an arrogant, statist elite. Let me use this opportunity to share with readers what America's 30th president thought about taxes and the people who worked hard to pay them.
"I want the people of America to be able to work less for the government and more for themselves," declared Coolidge in his inaugural address on March 4, 1925. "I want them to have the rewards of their own industry. That is the chief meaning of freedom. Until we can re-establish a condition under which the earnings of the people can be kept by the people, we are bound to suffer a very distinct curtailment of our liberty."
This flinty, frugal New Englander, who grew up respecting the hard-earned property of others, believed that the strength of the American nation was not centered in Washington, D.C. Once, as governor of Massachusetts, he asserted, "In a free republic a great government is the product of a great people.
They will look to themselves rather than government for success. The destiny, the greatness of America lies around the hearthstone. . . . Look well to the hearthstone; therein all hope for America lies."
Bill Clinton has raised taxes in many forms, several times, and once called taxes "contributions." As one wag put it, "Clinton never saw a tax he didn't like-and hike." Not Calvin Coolidge. As vice president, he strongly supported the steep reductions in income tax rates proposed by President Warren Harding's treasury secretary, Andrew Mellon. From the time he became president after Harding's untimely death in August 1923 until he left office in March 1929, Coolidge kept Mellon on the job and strengthened his own reputation as a committed tax cutter by urging Congress to enact further reductions. …